PART
XIX:
MUSCULOSKELETAL
INJURIES
Most connective tissue
injuries involve damage to the structural components of the tissue. Metabolic
states, such as a floxing, may also affect connective tissue health.
Degradation of the
extracellular matrix is also responsible for the pathogenesis of
osteoarthritis. Chondrocytes in articular cartilage with osteoarthritis may be
unresponsive to local growth factors resulting in decreased synthesis of matrix
components. According to several doctors that are treating some floxed persons,
the fluoroquinolone reaction activates a cascade of inflammatory events, and
chemical degradation of cells and metabolism, that ends up in a given state of
osteoarthritis, more or less symptomatic.
PROF.
DR. RALF STAHLMAN. CHARITÉ - UNIVERSITÄTSMEDIZIN
Fluoroquinolones
can cause tendon disorders as an adverse reaction associated with this class of
antimicrobials. We investigated aspects of the pathomechanism of
quinolone-induced tendotoxicity in human tenocytes focussing mainly on the
question whether fluoroquinolones induce apoptosis. Monolayers of human
tenocytes were incubated with ciprofloxacin or levofloxacin at different
concentrations (0, 3, 11, 30, 100 mg/L medium) for up to 4 days. Alterations in
synthesis of specific proteins were determined using immmunoblotting. At
concentrations which are achievable during quinolone therapy, 3 mg ciprofloxacin
or 10 mg levofloxacin/L medium significantly decreased type I collagen; similar
changes were observed for the 1-chain of the integrin receptor. Effects were
intensified at higher concentrations and longer incubation periods.
Furthermore, time- and concentration-dependent increases of the apoptosis
marker activated caspase-3 were found. Our results provide evidence that
apoptosis has to be considered as a final event in the pathogenesis of
fluoroquinolone-induced tendopathies. As a follow up to this project we will
study the effects of glucocorticoids alone and in combination with
fluoroquinolones on human tendon cells. In this part of the project, we hope to
provide biochemical evidence for the clinical observation that a treatment with
steroids has been recognized as a risk factor for quinolone-induced
tendopathies.
Apoptosis means programmed cell
death. Cells commit suicide when receive given signals, for example signals
emitted by quinolones.
Injury to connective tissue
involves damage to the cells and structural components of the tissue. Several
responses are triggered and a sequence of events begins to repair the tissue.
The reaction to injury includes vascular, cellular and biochemical responses. (The explanations concerning
connective tissue have been obtained from the work of Elzi Volk and others).
Three phases of the repair
process can be applied to the general healing of connective tissue. These
phases, however, may overlap. These responses prevent the spread of damaging
agents to nearby tissues, dispose of damaged cells, and replace damaged tissue
with newly synthesized components.
Acute inflammation phase: Immediately after the chemical
(floxing) injury, several vascular and cellular reactions initiate the response
known as inflammation. The primary purpose of inflammation is to rid the site
of damaged tissue cells and set the stage for tissue repair. Many of the events
that occur during this time initiate tissue repair. Leukocytes (white blood
cells), such as neutrophils and monocytes, accumulate within the damaged tissue
along with resident macrophages. Enzymes released from these cells help digest
necrotic cells and degrade matrix molecules; neutrophils and macrophages engulf
cell debris. Blood platelets release growth factors that stimulate new fiber
and matrix molecule synthesis.
Matrix and cellular proliferation phase: Chemical mediators released by
inflammatory cells stimulate migration and proliferation of fibroblasts, which
participate in the repair process. As you have seen this phase is profoundly
impaired by quinolones by means of many mechanisms among which there is
fibroblast metabolism impairment. Fibroblasts secrete fibronectin,
proteoglycans and small diameter Type III collagen fibers. In addition to these
fibers, newly formed capillary channels, clotting proteins, platelets and
freshly synthesized matrix molecules form granulation tissue. A floxed person
is deprived from this phase, up to an extent that defines the severity of
his/her floxing.
Remodeling phase: Remodeling reshapes and
strengthens damaged tissue by removing and reforming the matrix and replacing
cells. As repair progresses, inflammatory cells disappear, the number of blood
vessels and the density of fibroblasts decrease. The proportion of Type I
collagen to Type III collagen and the matrix organization increases. Collagen
fibers are reoriented in the direction of loading, especially in ligament
repair. As you know, there are many medical reports that indicate that
quinolones cause a faulty, disoriented remodeling of collagen fibers. Collagen
matures and elastin forms; tensile strength increases in normal people but not
much in floxed persons, who end up with very weak tendons. The remodeled tissue
does not completely resemble the original and thus the mechanical capabilities
of that tissue may be altered.

As an example of the
implications of a floxing over a joint, in the present edition of this paper,
we deal briefly only with the ankle joint and surrounding tissues, although the
quinolones also target any other joint in the body.
This picture 26 of the ankle area
shows the main tendons that are so commonly damaged by quinolones. It is a
class effect, that is to say, a direct injury, irrespective of one's build. The
colors mean: Red: achilles tendon; Green: flexor digitorum longus; Blue:
posterior tibial tendon; Purple: tibialis anterior.
As stated before, the
achilles tendon is not the one most affected by fluoroquinolones. The posterior
tibial tendon and the flexors of the toes are much more frequently affected,
and more severely, but contrary to the achilles, these tendons do not tend to
rupture so easily.
This picture
27 shows a dorsiflexion movement (forcing the toes upwards). This manoeuver
stretches the achilles tendon and stresses the posterior tibial tendon
and forces the flexor digitorum longus to work.
In severe reactions, this
movement performed against resistance on the tip of the toes, can cause
extremely incapacitating injuries in the posterior tibial and flexor digitorum
group of tendons, that require months to resolve.
This same gesture plus some
pronation is done during the contact phase of a normal running activity, which
from repetition can cause a devastating damage to the floxed athlete.
According to the studies of the
mainstream, industry-prone, researchers, "tendon disorders associated with fluoroquinolones
have been estimated to occur at a rate of approximately 15 to 20 per 100,000
patients." The real figures
are those stated in table 3 of this paper, that account for 100,000 patients
per 100,000 patients if they are given a high, yet approved, therapeutic dose.
This is so because of a direct toxic effect.
According to the most widespread
manufacturer's version of this problem, out of 100 cases of Achilles disorders,
"tendon
rupture occurred in 31% and tendinitis in 69%." That is again an incorrect figure because
ruptures are much less common than that. They also tell us "the average
time between the start of treatment to the onset of symptoms was 13 days, with
a range of 1 to 90 days". This means that they have only
studied report of ruptures associated with quinolones up to 90 days after the
start of treatment, whereas in reality they occur up to many months later.
One of their studies found that
50% of patients with fluoroquinolone-induced tendinitis recovered in 1 month.
In another study, 25% of the patients had symptoms that persisted for at least
2 months. So they conclude, "even with early diagnosis and management,
discontinuance of the fluoroquinolone, and placement of the tendons at rest,
tendinitis heals slowly". We
would like to know how slow would they rate the healing of many athletes with
unremitting and incapacitating tendinitis after 4, 5 or 7 years of suffering
from quinolone toxicity.
There have been reports of
patients with fluoroquinolone-associated ruptures of the Achilles tendon in
which histopathology was obtained. In one patient who had a rupture, the
histopathology showed necrosis along with neovascularization, multiple
fissures, and interstitial edema, but no inflammatory cell infiltrate.
Histopathology in a second case of ruptured Achilles tendon showed necrosis and
cystic changes that are not found in non-drug-associated tendinopathies.
Another patient had pain and
swelling of one Achilles tendon 9 months after only a 1-week course of
ciprofloxacin (500 mg bid). Biopsy of the tendon was done 4 months after the
onset of symptoms. Histologic examination revealed abnormal fiber arrangement
and structure with fibrotic areas, hypercellularity with some nuclei being more
rounded, neovascularization, and increased glycosaminoglycans in the
extracellular matrix. These histologic findings are similar to those in tendon
overuse injuries in athletes.
In summary, the damage is
extensive and deep on tissues that have very little capacity to regenerate, so
the injuries linger on for a long time or become chronic or permanent.
But again, for the industry and
their well paid or brainwashed doctors, our group of 42 floxed persons, mostly
young healthy athletes with zero previous health problems, is a group of people
with special risk factors prone to rupture their tendons. Read what they always
add to any report on side effects of quinolones: "....................effects such as
tendon ruptures, which may occur in the absence of any medication, particularly
since the reported cases frequently had coexisting risk factors. However,
clinical reports, histopathologic findings, and an experimental model support a
causal relationship between fluoroquinolone use and tendon ruptures". ../.. "Since
it is often difficult to establish causality for individual cases, efforts to
quantify the risk of tendon ruptures should be viewed as only estimates. There
may be a bias in over reporting an association between tendon rupture and
fluoroquinolone use, involving cases that might have spontaneously occurred
without the medication. On the other hand, the association may be unrecognized,
and therefore some cases may be underreported". This
sort of disqualification of every study makes doctors not pay attention to
ADVERSE EFFECTS at all.
Some researchers are more
independent from industry: A case report described an individual who had 9
months of symptoms after a 1-week course of fluoroquinolones: "The
histopathology in this patient is particularly noteworthy. Abnormal biopsy
findings, consistent with a reactive healing process, were found at 4 months,
suggesting these medications may have prolonged effects on tendons. The
presence of a cystic change in another patient suggests the pathophysiologic
changes associated with fluoroquinolones may not be completely reversible, at
least in some cases. The prolonged symptoms associated with increased
glycosaminoglycans of the tendon in one patient who had only a 1-week course of
antibiotics and the cystic changes in another patient support mechanisms for
ruptures to occur long after the antibiotic therapy has been discontinued. An
abnormal reactive healing response, or cystic degeneration, may be responsible
for our case of the rupture that occurred 6 months after ciprofloxacin therapy
was discontinued".
It follows: "Our cases add to the anecdotal
evidence suggesting a causal relationship between fluoroquinolones and tendon
rupture. Additionally, these cases highlight the broad nature of tendon
ruptures that may be associated with this class of medications. Tendons other
than the Achilles may be affected by the use of fluoroquinolones. Furthermore,
a considerable delay may exist between the administration of a fluoroquinolone
and the spontaneous rupture of a tendon. In one of our cases, the delay was 6
months after completion of a course of ciprofloxacin. However, evidence from
previous reports suggests that such a delay is possible. The rat model shows
that fluoroquinolones may produce inflammation of the tendon within 1 day after
their administration. An abnormal
healing response to fluoroquinolone-associated inflammation, or cystic degeneration
may produce effects months after completion of even a short course of a
fluoroquinolone".
The conclusions were: "Fluoroquinolone-associated
tendon disruption, including rupture, is well described in the literature.
Although the Achilles tendon is the most susceptible site, other tendons may be
affected. Typically, spontaneous tendon rupture occurs during or shortly after
a course of therapy, but symptoms may occur months after taking
fluoroquinolones. Whether fluoroquinolones should be used in patients with a
history of tendon problems or with risk factors for the development of tendon
ruptures depends on the seriousness of the infection and the alternatives
available. Awareness of the association between tendon disorders and
fluoroquinolones may lead to enhanced surveillance, which should be extended to
sites beyond the Achilles tendon and to periods of months after a course of
these antibiotics".
Other problems diagnosed by means
of MRI's to the floxed persons that participated in the creation of this flox
paper include (for the ankle):
tendinitis of the achilles
tendinitis of the posterior tibial tendon,
flexor digitorum and tibialis anterior
tenosynovitis with inflammation of the tendons
sheath
synovial infiltrate on tendons
stenosing tenosynovitis in one or more major
tendons
partial ruptures of one or more of the major
tendons
tendon cysts
Figure 28 (with permission; sorry
for the low quality of the file received). Look what "mild" tendinitis and tenosynovitis look like in a young
healthy athlete three years and three months after unnecesary exposure to
quinolones for a minor suspected bladder infection. Here, you (or your doctor)
can see some fluid accumulation and paratendon engorssment in the posterior
tibialis tendon and flexor digitorum longus. It is a cross section of the ankle,
with the achilles tendon in the lower right side of the picture.
And in the following sequence of
a MRI plane of a knee, you can see the irreversible injury caused by
ciprofloxacin to a young and previously healthy young man.
This is a cross section (figure 29)
(with
permission) of the knee of a floxed athlete
41 years old, that have never had any problem before, completely attributable
to ciprofloxacin. He also has a MRI taken one year before the intoxication with
quinolones, taken as a volunteer for a rutinary study for leg alignments and
gait analysis. So there is proof that no problem existed before.
In this image, the central dark
item is the femur close to the knee. The upper oval shape is the patella. The
two white stripes that appear in the contact between the patella and the femur
are the cartilages of both bones. The signal of the cartilage of the patella is
engrossed and diffuse, indicating that a first grade osteoarthritis has
developed.